I received a lovely email from a woman named Sharon, who had just read a review of my memoir. She wrote, “I just read a review of your memoir Mama’s Boy, Preacher’s Son. The clinging-yet-hostile attitude of your mother, the remoteness and judgmentalness [sic] of your father, and the machismo of your brother Mike are all factors in the development of your homosexuality in the first place. Homosexuality and transgenderism [sic] are not inborn. But they are preventable and treatable. Treating a sick person humanely is good; treating a sick person as if he or she were well is not…The sooner you do your inner work and heal your masculinity impairment, the sooner you will cease this fool’s errand and have the kind of life everyone really wants.”
Thanks for the tips, Sharon! I’ve never heard anything like this before! It’s such a relief to know I am sick and can be cured!
Aside from the arrogance of Sharon’s statement that, if I follow her advice, I will “have the kind of life everyone really wants” (my only reply to her email was “I am perfectly happy with my life the way it is, thank you”), I am struck by her definition of what is “good.” Apparently she thinks convincing people they are sickos is good for them (even if such negative barrages lead to higher rates of suicide, drug abuse, and other self-destructive behaviors). Well, sorry, Sharon, that just reminds me a bit too much of my Dad’s pronouncement before speaking us “This is going to hurt me a lot more than it is going to hurt you.” I didn’t buy that kind of malarkey then, and I don’t buy yours now.
The “judgmentalness” that I have a real problem with is not my father’s but that of folks like Sharon, who feel like they have the right to tell other people how to live their lives. Now that is a real sickness.




